SIGNAL BROKER - AI GAMEPLAY COMMENTATOR SCORECARD
=================================================
A method, not a score. Watch ten minutes of one recording or one session of
your own game, and fill in a row each time the commentator speaks. The full
method is at https://thesignalbroker.com/blog/how-to-evaluate-an-ai-gameplay-commentator/

Date: ____________   Game: ______________________   Session length: ________
Build (Help/About): ______________   Role: SPECTATOR / PLAYER   Talkativeness: ___
Source: recording / my own session       OBS recorded: yes / no

HOW TO FILL A ROW
  Relevant?  hit = names or reacts to something visible or just finished
             miss = wrong object or wrong outcome, or filler that fits any game
             trivial = relevant but not worth a line (not a miss)
  On time?   immediate = within a beat of the moment
             a beat late = the moment is still alive when the line lands
             stale = the scene has already changed (menus, respawn, next play)
  Repeat?    yes = the same point, phrase or joke again with no awareness of it
             (referring back to an earlier moment is memory, not a repeat)
  Keep?      your taste: would you want that line in the session, yes or no

----+------------------------+----------------------+---------+-----------+------+-----
 m:ss| What was on screen     | What he said (short) | Relev.  | On time?  | Rep. | Keep
----+------------------------+----------------------+---------+-----------+------+-----
    |                        |                      |         |           |      |
----+------------------------+----------------------+---------+-----------+------+-----
    |                        |                      |         |           |      |
----+------------------------+----------------------+---------+-----------+------+-----
    |                        |                      |         |           |      |
----+------------------------+----------------------+---------+-----------+------+-----
    |                        |                      |         |           |      |
----+------------------------+----------------------+---------+-----------+------+-----
    |                        |                      |         |           |      |
----+------------------------+----------------------+---------+-----------+------+-----
    |                        |                      |         |           |      |
----+------------------------+----------------------+---------+-----------+------+-----
    |                        |                      |         |           |      |
----+------------------------+----------------------+---------+-----------+------+-----
    |                        |                      |         |           |      |
----+------------------------+----------------------+---------+-----------+------+-----
    |                        |                      |         |           |      |
----+------------------------+----------------------+---------+-----------+------+-----
    |                        |                      |         |           |      |
----+------------------------+----------------------+---------+-----------+------+-----
    |                        |                      |         |           |      |
----+------------------------+----------------------+---------+-----------+------+-----
    |                        |                      |         |           |      |
----+------------------------+----------------------+---------+-----------+------+-----

SILENCES (each quiet stretch longer than a minute)
  from-to   | what was on screen            | right / wrong / voice recovering
  ----------+-------------------------------+---------------------------------
            |                               |
            |                               |
            |                               |
  Right silence: a menu, a loading screen, a cutscene, nothing in particular.
  Wrong silence: a clear moment passed unremarked while the Broker Bar read
  LISTENING (not PAUSED). VOICE RECOVERING is a service state, not a judgement.
  In a recording you cannot see the Bar, so judge silence by the screen.

TOTALS
  Lines heard ____  Hits ____  Misses ____  Trivial ____
  Immediate ____  A beat late ____  Stale ____  Repeats ____
  Wrong silences ____  Voice recovering ____
  Verdict in one sentence: _________________________________________________

NOTES
  * Signal Broker's words and voice are generated by AI; a line can be wrong,
    repeated or badly timed. This sheet records your own judgement of one
    session; it is not a benchmark and the maker publishes no scores.
  * Change one thing at a time between runs (role, Talkativeness, game).
  * If you publish a sheet, say which build, role and Talkativeness you used.